Help
Yahoo! Kids
"KIDS HOME PARENTS

PARENTS

Review: 'Disney's A Christmas Carol'

Review: 'Disney's A Christmas Carol'

3-D adaptation of classic holiday tale may scare young kids.

 

See ten clips and videos from "Disney's A Christmas Carol."

 

Charles Dickens' 19th-century classic comes to life again in this 3-D adaptation, which faithfully follows the original tale.

 

Seven Christmas Eves after the death of his business partner, Jacob Marley (voiced by Gary Oldman), miserly money lender Ebenezer Scrooge (Jim Carrey) spends the day complaining about the town's holiday cheer ("Bah, humbug!"), terrorizing his put-upon clerk Bob Cratchit (also Oldman), and refusing his nephew Fred's (Colin Firth) invitation to Christmas supper.

 

That night, Scrooge is visited by Marley's ghost, who informs him that three spirits will appear to him to offer one last chance to change his life before it's too late. Scrooge is then summoned by the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Christmas Present, and Christmas Yet to Come (all played by Carrey), each of whom gives the crotchety old man a peek at defining moments in his life and possible future -- as well as the life of poor-but-happy Cratchit, whose crippled son Tiny Tim (Oldman again) is sickly but still filled with holiday cheer.

 

Director Robert Zemeckis continues to perfect the motion-capture animation he revolutionized with "The Polar Express," and the result is quite breathtaking in "A Christmas Carol." From the pimples on an adolescent's face to the coins on a corpse's eyes, the technology accounts for a remarkable degree of detail.

 

The 3-D, in particular, is fantastic -- albeit occasionally frightening (a few shots may cause audiences to jump from their seats). With a rubber-faced actor like Carrey as the star, it's no wonder that the characters' expressions and gestures are so startlingly realistic.

 

Of course, the downside to all of the realism is that the ghost scenes are actually quite frightening -- not Beowulf terrifying, but downright scary nonetheless. The spook factor is unfortunate for parents who will naturally assume that animation plus holiday classic equals cinematic fun for the whole family.

 

For those with harder-to-rattle clans, this is a touching and haunting adaptation of a story most of us know by heart in one form or the other. Carrey's genius at physical comedy is evident throughout the film in small moments like when Scrooge does a jig, sings along with carolers, or slides down a railing. While there aren't many huge laughs, there's enough levity to break through the otherwise somber nature of Scrooge's time-traveling, life-changing visits to Christmases past, present, and future.

 

Oldman and Firth are, as always, fine supporting players, and Robin Wright Penn (a Beowulf alum) adds a wistful, feminine vulnerability to the only woman Scrooge ever loved. With the current economic doom and gloom, this is a well-timed holiday narrative about hope, redemption, and love.

 

Parents Need to Know

 

Parents need to know that, unlike "The Polar Express," this Robert Zemeckis adaptation of a classic holiday tale is too intense both visually and in content for families with very young children.

 

At its heart, Charles Dickens' "A Christmas Carol" is a ghost story, and not only are the many spirits very creepy at times, but the 3-D technology makes certain scenes -- as when the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come's red-eyed black stallions jump out at the audience -- all the scarier. And the realistic nature of the motion capture technology often makes the movie seem more like live action (and thus more intense) than animation.

 

But on the other hand, the language is mild (British slang like "bugger" and "blast") and the drinking limited to Christmas toasts. And the messages are all quite positive, as Ebenezer Scrooge's (Jim Carrey) transformation is one of literature's ultimate stories of redemption and hope, even in the bleakest of times.

 

Families Can Talk About

 

  • Families can talk about the lessons that Scrooge learns. How does he change throughout the movie? What is the story trying to teach us about not just Christmas, but about human behavior in general?

 

  • How are the themes of A Christmas Carol still relevant more than 200 years after it was originally written? Kids: How can you act generously during the holidays and year round?

 

  • Do you think the 3-D technology enhances the movie, or would it have been as good/better without it?

 

Studio: Walt Disney Pictures Director: Robert Zemeckis Cast: Jim Carrey, Colin Firth, Gary Oldman, Robin Wright Penn Genre: Family and Kids Run time: 96 minutes Theatrical release: 11/6/2009 MPAA rating: PG MPAA explanation: scary sequences and images

 

Reviewed by Sandie Angulo Chen.

 

See more about 'Disney's A Christmas Carol' at Common Sense Media.

Related:  movies

Other Parents Say…

Showing 1-9 Comments of 9
  • Avatar
    Posted by Charyl Mon Nov 9, 2009 5:37pm PST

    I feel the 'fright' intensity of the ghosts was needlessly too frightening which kind of spoils the other amazing aspects of the 3D/special effects. I would not bring a younger child to see this which is disappointing for a Christmas annimated film.

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by Madelyn Tue Nov 10, 2009 11:37am PST

    so? having no fright or even wee bit intense moments would make it BORING. and, it wouldn't be a christmas carol anymore!

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by rachb38 Wed Nov 11, 2009 11:35am PST

    man this is very dissapointing i dont think t should be in 3-D

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by Susan Sat Nov 14, 2009 12:57pm PST

    I took my two children to see this movie. I had very low expectations as I do not feel any previous adaptation has done this beautiful tale justice. How many people have actually read the book? The language is nearly lyrical, the message powerful. That is very hard to convey on screen however I was very pleased with this film. We too saw it in 3-D and I thought it was fantastic. No, this is not a film for the little kids - not because of any "spooky characters" but because they are too young to grasp the message. The scene where the Ghost of Christmas Present reveals Ignorance and Want is a wonderful jumping off point for serious discussions with our kids about charity and kindness all the year long. I think that the reviewer completely missed the point of the film and the message.

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by Erika Wed Nov 18, 2009 8:11am PST

    the movie sounds great my kids and i would love to see the movie

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by lqyryan209 Wed Nov 18, 2009 11:10am PST

    try to order from http://www.gobuyvogue.com good quality and best price accept paypal safe and easy shopping!!! Yay!!! sell nike $29-$42 clothing $12-$35,handbags $32,FREE SHIPPING They offer cheap nike shoes,nfl jerseys,brand handbags,cheap jeans and tshirts,paypal accept http://www.gobuyvogue.com I do often to order from http://www.gobuyvogue.com wholesale jersey,shoes,jean,cap,handbag,sunglass,short,wallet,watches,belts jewelry software and so on. All products sold at the website with good quality,free shipping,the price is very cheap. They can accept paypal. http://www.gobuyvogue.com Hope this is useful for you

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by Chris P Thu Nov 19, 2009 6:46pm PST

    FANTASTIC movie! The 3D effects were top notch! It appeared to snow in the the theater! My 6 y/o got a bit spooked during the grim reaper scene, but other than that tried to reach out and grab snowflakes during the movie! The scenes where Ebenezer flies around with each spirit were as if you were flying in a helicopter around the town and different scenes! BRAVO!

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by Bad Kitty Mon Nov 23, 2009 11:53am PST

    I was disappointed by this movie. Taking the children was a waste because the story was not clear enough for someone who hasn't read the book to get the message. The scenes with the ghosts seemed to be more about the animation tricks (i.e. scary) than actually conveying the message of the story. My daughter thought it was scary and didn't really get it.

    Report Abuse
  • Avatar
    Posted by Bad Kitty Mon Nov 23, 2009 11:53am PST

    I was disappointed by this movie. Taking the children was a waste because the story was not clear enough for someone who hasn't read the book to get the message. The scenes with the ghosts seemed to be more about the animation tricks (i.e. scary) than actually conveying the message of the story. My daughter thought it was scary and didn't really get it.

    Report Abuse
Showing 1-9 Comments of 9

Leave Your Comment